Great Amherst Mystery

**This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links.

Lindsay and Madison discuss the Great Amherst Mystery, as well as why you should avoid men with black eyes, that it’s not okay to treat people’s homes like an oddities museum, and that if a poltergeist throws a knife at you, that’s your cue to leave.

Information pulled from the following sources:

• 2022 Halifax Examiner article by Suzanne Rent

• 2021 National Library of Medicine Circulating Now blog post by Nicole Baker

• 1998 Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 14 article by Diane Tye

• 1888 Darke County Democratic Advocate

• 1888 The Tennessean article

• Amherst website

• History of the Hubbell Family by Walter Hubbell

• The Haunted House: A true ghost story by Walter Hubbell

• Wikipedia

Go check out our friends Alannah and Leanne over at the Booze and Ghouls podcast.

Pre-order your copy of the 2023 Independent True Crime Podcast calendar at podcastcalendars.com and get $5 off your order by using our promo code, OLDECRIMERS. And if you order before November 30, 2022, you can get an additional 10% off!

Meet the new Instacart+. Get unlimited free delivery on $35+ orders, 5% credit back on pickup, & more. Credit back excludes alcohol. Terms apply.

Become a member on Buy Me A Coffee for as little as $1/month to support the show. 

You can write to us at: Ye Olde Crime Podcast, PO Box 341, Wyoming, MN 55092. Join the conversation over at the Cultiv8 Discord and join the Olde Crimers Cubby to chat with us and other listeners of the show.

Leave us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, Podchaser, Spotify, Podcast Addict, Audible, or Goodpods!

Don’t forget to follow us on Twitter, Instagram, Threads, Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube.

Buy us a Coffee